When should I choose a restricted desktop assessment vs a formal property valuation report?

Restricted assessment (desktop) — when it fits

  • Most residential properties and uncomplicated commercial assets
  • Uses recent comparable sales, sales history and other market data
  • No physical inspection; efficient turnaround and lower cost
  • Clear conclusion to help trustees determine market price at the valuation date, consistent with a willing buyer/willing seller test.

Formal property valuation report — when to step up 

  • Formal independent valuations are required for complex/specialised commercial or rural assets, limited local evidence, or heavy fund weighting
  • Includes method selection (valuation method), comparable sales analysis, assumptions and relevant factors
    Prepared by a qualified independent valuer with documented independence and credentials
  • Provides a defensible, determined property value to satisfy annual SMSF audit requirements